News & guides / Guide
Guide

Is it worth grading your Pokémon card? PSA vs CGC vs BGS

When grading a Pokémon card makes money and when it doesn't, how PSA, CGC, BGS and TAG compare, and a simple rule to decide in under a minute.

Cardrity News4 min read
Is it worth grading your Pokémon card? PSA vs CGC vs BGS
The rule of thumb

Grade a card when its PSA 10 price is at least 3 times its raw price and you're confident it's clean. Otherwise the fees and the chance of a 9 or lower usually eat the profit.

How to decide

  1. Look up the raw Near Mint price and the PSA 10 price on the card's Cardrity page.
  2. Subtract the grading fee and shipping from the PSA 10 price.
  3. Check the card's centering, corners, edges and surface. Be honest: most pack-fresh cards are 9s, not 10s.
  4. If a 9 would still be worth more than raw plus fees, it's usually safe to send.

PSA vs CGC vs BGS vs TAG

CompanyBest for
PSAThe highest resale value for most Pokémon cards. A PSA 10 usually sells for more than any other company's 10.
CGCCheaper and often faster. Strong for modern cards and Japanese cards.
BGSSubgrades for centering, corners, edges and surface. A Black Label 10 is rare and valuable.
TAGNewer, with detailed scan-based reports. Growing but less established for resale.

What stops a 10

Centering is the most common problem: if one border is clearly wider than the other, a 10 is unlikely. Then look for white specks on the back corners and edges, and scratches on the holo when you tilt it under light.

Cardrity Pro can grade a card from photos and estimate its likely PSA grade before you pay to send it in.

Grade a card from photosGet a likely PSA grade, centering and flaws from two photos (Cardrity Pro).
Try grading
Keep reading
NewsAura Seeker: Japan's Mega Lucario Z ex set lands November 27Leak & rumourFlowing Fists: the next English Pokémon set after Delta ReignNewsDelta Reign is out: the chase cards and what they're selling for