News & guides / Guide
Guide
Is it worth grading your Pokémon card? PSA vs CGC vs BGS
When grading a Pokémon card makes money and when it doesn't, how PSA, CGC, BGS and TAG compare, and a simple rule to decide in under a minute.

The rule of thumb
Grade a card when its PSA 10 price is at least 3 times its raw price and you're confident it's clean. Otherwise the fees and the chance of a 9 or lower usually eat the profit.
How to decide
- Look up the raw Near Mint price and the PSA 10 price on the card's Cardrity page.
- Subtract the grading fee and shipping from the PSA 10 price.
- Check the card's centering, corners, edges and surface. Be honest: most pack-fresh cards are 9s, not 10s.
- If a 9 would still be worth more than raw plus fees, it's usually safe to send.
PSA vs CGC vs BGS vs TAG
| Company | Best for |
|---|---|
| PSA | The highest resale value for most Pokémon cards. A PSA 10 usually sells for more than any other company's 10. |
| CGC | Cheaper and often faster. Strong for modern cards and Japanese cards. |
| BGS | Subgrades for centering, corners, edges and surface. A Black Label 10 is rare and valuable. |
| TAG | Newer, with detailed scan-based reports. Growing but less established for resale. |
What stops a 10
Centering is the most common problem: if one border is clearly wider than the other, a 10 is unlikely. Then look for white specks on the back corners and edges, and scratches on the holo when you tilt it under light.
Cardrity Pro can grade a card from photos and estimate its likely PSA grade before you pay to send it in.
Grade a card from photosGet a likely PSA grade, centering and flaws from two photos (Cardrity Pro).
Try grading